Looking to get your next pair of glasses online but aren’t sure which retailer is right for you? Today we’re going to do a side-by-side comparison of three of the most popular online glasses shops – Zenni Optical, Warby Parker, and EyeBuyDirect.
Last updated: January 7, 2025
(This page contains affiliate links. OGR may receive compensation if you click a link and make a purchase.)
- Home Try-On
- Virtual Try-On
- Prescription
- Sells Contacts
- Shipping
- Payment Methods
- Return Policy
- Warranty
- Accepts VisionInsurance
- Single, Bifocal, Progressive, Reading
- Free over $89/$4.95 Standard/$15 Express
- Credit/Debit, PayPal, Amazon
- 30 days
- 30 days
- No
- Single, Bifocal, Progressive, Reading
- Free over $119/$5.95 Standard/$19 Express
- Credit/Debit, PayPal, Amazon
- 14 days
- 1-year defect replacement
- No
- Single, Progressive, Reading
- Free (including Home Try-On and returns)
- Vision Insurance, Credit/Debit, Apple Pay
- 30 days
- 6-month free scratched lens replacement
- Yes (select providers)
Summary
You can get a great pair of glasses at each of these eyewear companies for much less than you’d pay at most optical stores.
Zenni and EyeBuyDirect in particular offer super-affordable frames (as low as $6-7 a pair).
For under $30, you can easily get new glasses with shipping at either of these sites.
In addition to regular eyeglasses, Zenni and EyeBuyDirect also sell prescription sunglasses and kids’ glasses.
Warby Parker is more of a boutique store compared to Zenni and EyeBuyDirect.
Their glasses start at $95, but that includes prescription lenses as well as a bunch of extras that cost additional at other stores.
They also have several retail locations throughout the U.S. and Canada, where you can go and try frames on in person or get your glasses adjusted if they don’t fit perfectly.
You can also get an eye exam in some stores.
For more on how each retailer stacks up, we compared them in the following ways:
Website/Ordering Experience
Ordering glasses through each of these opticals is straightforward and easy.
You can filter the selection by gender, shape, material, color, and size.
Zenni and EyeBuyDirect allow you to sort frames by price so you can easily find glasses in the price range you’re looking for.
Warby Parker allows you to sort by price for the $95 frames (their prices range from $95-$195.)
You can also filter their selection for frames that are available to be mailed to you for their free Home Try-On Program.
All three display customer reviews and ratings on their product pages for each frame, but only Zenni and EyeBuyDirect go a step further by including customer-uploaded photos, allowing you to see how others look in specific pairs of glasses.
They also all have a virtual try-on feature where you can either upload a photo of yourself or use your webcam in real-time to see how you’ll look with the glasses.
Once you’ve picked a pair and added it to your cart, you’re prompted to enter your prescription and select lens options via dropdown boxes or by typing in your numerical values.
Alternatively, you can upload a photo of your prescription instead of entering it in.
For your pupillary distance, you can enter it as either a single or dual value.
Interestingly, Zenni makes you enter your birth year when entering your prescription in.
They say it’s so they can provide age-appropriate lens recommendations.
Warby Parker’s ordering process is the simplest of the three.
You have a choice of uploading a picture of your prescription or you can provide your doctor’s contact info and they will call and get it.
In addition to their website, Warby Parker has an excellent iOS app that you can use to try glasses on virtually, order, and pay using Apple Pay.
If you get stuck or need help at any point during the ordering process, each company offers help via phone, live chat, or email.
Verdict:
All three sites are easy to navigate and order from.
If you want more customization over your lens options, Zenni or EyeBuyDirect is the way to go.
You can pick and choose only the coatings you want to pay for (such as anti-reflective, UV-blocking, sunglass tint/gradient, etc.).
Otherwise, Warby Parker makes the ordering process simple and clean.
You don’t need to worry about knowing how to read and enter your prescription.
They also include UV-blocking, anti-glare, scratch and water-resistant coatings on all their prescription lenses at no additional cost.
Selection
Zenni:
Of the three, Zenni has the largest selection with over 2000 frames for sale.
They come in all shapes, styles, and colors – plastic, metal, rimless, and even prescription sports glasses and goggles (not for swimming though)!
You’ll also find over 200 kids glasses, from little kids to teens.
Even though many of their frames are already low-cost, Zenni offers additional discounts and promos if you’re in the military or a first responder.
All orders come with anti-scratch + UV-blocking lens coatings at no additional cost.
They also offer up to a -20.00 distance correction prescription strength.
Up until recently, Zenni only sold in-house designs, but they now sell some brand name eyewear including Calvin Klein, Marc Jacobs, and Kate Spade.
- Lens Indexes
- Prescription Range
- Correction Type
- Coatings Available
- Sunglasses Lens Options
- Sunglasses Lens Colors
- 1.50 to 1.67 (high index)
- -20.00 to +12.00
- Single, Bifocal, Progressive, Reading
- Anti-Scratch, UV-Blocking, Anti-Glare, Blue Light Blocking
- Gradient, Polarized, Mirrored, Transitions®
- Gray, Green, Amber, Blue, Purple, Pink, Yellow
EyeBuyDirect:
Get 30% off $100 or more at EyeBuyDirect with code: EYE30
EyeBuyDirect has nearly as big a choice of eyeglass and sunglass frames as Zenni.
Though they have a smaller selection of kids frames.
There are also designer frames from the likes of Ray-Ban, Oakley, and Coach.
All EyeBuyDirect orders come with anti-scratch coating on the lenses.
They also offer ultra high-index (super-thin) lenses up to 1.74.
For distance corrections, they make prescriptions up to -16.00.
- Lens Indexes
- Prescription Range
- Correction Type
- Coatings Available
- Sunglasses Lens Options
- Sunglasses Lens Colors
- 1.50 to 1.74 (ultra high index)
- -16.00 to +12.00
- Single, Bifocal, Progressive, Reading
- Anti-Scratch, UV-Blocking, Anti-Glare, Water-Repellent, Blue Light Blocking
- Gradient, Polarized, Mirrored, Transitions®
- Gray, Brown, Green, Purple, Blue
Renew Your Rx with a 5-min Online Test
Warby Parker:
Of the three, Warby Parker has the smallest selection of eyeglasses and sunglasses.
However, they introduce new designs and collections every few months, and often pair up with influencers and celebs like Justin Timberlake and Emma Chamberlain for limited edition frames.
They also sell low bridge fit glasses (sometimes called “Asian fit”) for those with low nose bridges or high cheekbones.
Warby Parker’s standard optical lens included in every order is the 1.59-index polycarbonate (thinner and more impact-resistant than lower index lenses).
For non-prescription sunglasses, they use the regular CR-39 lens.
They also include UV-blocking, anti-reflective, anti-scratch, and water repellent coatings with each pair.
They will make distance correction strengths up to -18.00.
- Lens Indexes
- Prescription Range
- Correction Type
- Coatings Available
- Sunglasses Lens Options
- Sunglasses Lens Colors
- 1.50 to 1.74 (ultra high index)
- -18.00 to +6.00
- Single, Progressive, Reading
- Anti-Scratch, UV-Blocking, Anti-Glare, Water-Repellent, Blue-Light Blocking
- Gradient, Polarized, Mirrored, Light-Responsive
- Gray, Brown, Green, Blue
Verdict:
In terms of sheer number of glasses and styles, Zenni takes the cake in this category with over 2000 frames available.
They have everything from kids’ frames to sport goggles, as well as Rx sunglasses and clip-on sets.
They also have the largest prescription range that they will fill (from -20.00 to +12.00).
If you’re looking for an ultra high-index lens though, you’ll want to go with EyeBuyDirect or Warby Parker.
Quality
The quality and durability of the glasses from Zenni, EyeBuyDirect, or Warby Parker depends on the specific pair you get.
In general, Zenni and EyeBuyDirect’s frames, especially their super low-priced ones, have a cheaper feel and construction.
However, many people are pleased with the quality of their frames and lenses given the cost.
See this comparison of a Zenni pair versus a similarly-styled Oakley.
(Do note that EyeBuyDirect sells select frames from Ray-Ban and Oakley too.)
Some people don’t even notice any difference in quality between the glasses they paid a few hundred bucks for at their local optical shop and their much less expensive pair from Zenni or EyeBuyDirect!
Warby Parker’s frames are more uniform in quality since the company mostly sells full-rim acetate frames.
Though the difference in quality between their glasses and a mid-range Zenni or EyeBuyDirect frame is pretty negligible.
Verdict:
For the cost, the quality of eyeglasses and lenses from Zenni, EyeBuyDirect, or Warby Parker is very good.
You can get a decent pair of glasses from all three stores that, with proper care, will last you a while.
Cost
Frames:
Acetate, stainless steel, or plastic frames are the least expensive, while sunglasses and titanium eyeglasses cost more.
At Zenni and EyeBuyDirect, you can find glasses for less than $10.
EyeBuyDirect starts at $6:
While Zenni has glasses as low as $6.95:
Zenni’s most expensive non-designer frames go for $59.95.
EyeBuyDirect’s premium RFLKT line costs up to $90 a pair.
Both shops offer several selections in between both ends of their price ranges too.
Warby Parker’s glasses most inexpensive frames cost $95, but includes the cost of single-vision Rx lenses.
Most of their acetate frames are $95, with their metal and mixed material frames priced at $145, $175, or $195.
Get cashback for glasses and other purchases from TopCashBack
Lenses:
Zenni:
Zenni Optical includes single vision prescriptions with anti-scratch and UV-blocking coatings in the cost of the frame for the standard (1.50) to mid-index (1.57) lenses.
Anti-reflective coating costs $4.95.
If you want thinner, more impact-resistant polycarbonate (1.59) lenses, it’s an additional $11.95.
Of the three, Zenni is the only one that sells the Trivex 1.53 index lens.
What’s Trivex? It’s similar to polycarbonate in that it’s thinner and more impact-resistant than standard plastic lenses.
But it’s 10% lighter than polycarbonate, and produces crisper images.
Best for low-medium strength prescriptions, the Trivex lens will set you back $29.95.
However, while they sell Trivex lenses, Zenni doesn’t offer the ultra high-index 1.74 lens for super strong prescriptions.
Sunglass lenses start at $7.95 for tint only.
If you want polarized lenses (reduced glare from shiny objects or surfaces), they cost $35.95 and up.
Photochromic (light-adjusting) lenses start at $29.95, and Transitions® lenses go from $89.95 and up.
Best Prescription Glasses Under $100
EyeBuyDirect:
EyeBuyDirect’s basic lens package includes single-vision 1.50-index lens with anti-scratch and anti-reflective coatings for $6.95.
If you want UV-blocking, it’s best to get the polycarbonate lens ($19.95) since it’s included in the cost.
Otherwise you’ll pay $4.95 extra for it with other lens types. UV-blocking is not offered in the 1.50 index.
For very strong prescriptions, you can get the super-thin 1.74 lens for $105.
Sunglasses tint only is $4.95, while polarized lenses cost an additional $59.
Photochromic (light-adjusting) lenses cost $35.95. They also sell Transitions® lenses for $99.
Warby Parker:
Warby Parker’s standard lens package consists of single-vision polycarbonate (1.59) lenses plus anti-scratch, anti-reflective, UV-blocking, and superhydrophobic (water-resistant) coatings.
All of this is included in the cost of the frame.
Unlike Zenni and EyeBuyDirect, Warby Parker does not offer a highly customizable amount of additional options since their standard lenses already come with all of the above treatments.
They do sell high-index lenses for stronger prescriptions.
1.67 lenses cost an additional $50 and ultra high-index 1.74 lenses cost $150 extra.
Single vision prescription sunglasses cost $195, and include your choice of tint (including gradients), polarization, UV-blocking, and anti-scratch coatings.
Verdict:
Zenni is the lowest cost retailer of the three (with EyeBuyDirect a close second).
With a large selection of ultra low-cost frames plus single-vision lenses included, you can save a lot of money even paying for shipping.
Customer Service
As with any business, people have had both positive and negative experiences at all three stores, so your experience will very much depend on your specific circumstances and the representative that helps you, should you need assistance.
That being said, below is the general consensus we’ve gathered from scouring multiple reviews from various sources.
Zenni has had somewhat of a spotty record with their customer service in years past, but have since improved.
The overall consensus is that they are strict sticklers with their policies and aren’t as easy to work with if you’re trying to correct or return an item.
EyeBuyDirect generally has solid customer service as there aren’t as many reported issues with returns or exchanges in most reviews.
However, many have commented that their shipping times can be very long, and that contacting customer service for their shipment status involves some back and forth.
Warby Parker has become almost synonymous with great customer service.
They’re known for being personable and give associates the authorization to make the customer happy with unexpected assistance.
The experience in their retail stores is also exemplary – associates are friendly and helpful, but not intrusive if you’re just browsing and trying on different frames.
Verdict:
Warby Parker is the clear winner in this category, given that their number one ground rule is to “Treat customers the way we’d like to be treated.”
Insurance
Zenni and EyeBuyDirect don’t accept any vision insurance plans.
However, they can take payment in the form of a credit or debit card associated with a flexible spending account (FSA).
You can also submit your itemized receipt to your insurance provider if you have out-of-network reimbursement benefits.
Warby Parker accepts many insurance plans as payment including UnitedHealthcare, Spectera, Guardian Vision, and Davis Vision plans.
They also accept credit/debit cards associated with an FSA account.
Quick Tip: Prescription sunglasses are covered under vision insurance!
Verdict:
Warby Parker is the winner here since they are an in-network provider under a few insurance plans. However, you can still submit itemized receipts to your vision plan as an out-of-network claim from any of the three stores.
Extras/Accessories
Zenni:
For a few extra bucks, you can engrave an icon or text on the inside of the right temple arm ($1.95), or on the outside of both arms ($3.95).
They also sell clip-on shades for each frame ($3.95 – $5.95) if you don’t want to buy a separate pair of sunglasses or get light-adjusting lenses.
EyeBuyDirect:
For $10, you can add some extra flair to your glasses with a small crystal added to each lens.
EyeBuyDirect also has glasses specifically for digital screen use that come with EyeZen™ lenses.
They’re a combination of blue-light blocking lenses with a small reading enhancement (ADD power) at the bottom of each lens to help combat eye strain for people who are in front of digital devices several hours a day.
Warby Parker:
Aside from glasses, Warby Parker a few eyewear-related items like a lens cleaning kit.
The most useful optical accessories are their foldable magnetic hard case and their lens cleaning spray kit.
Shipping
Both Zenni and EyeBuyDirect ship to all 50 states, as well as internationally.
Zenni’s standard shipping for the U.S. + U.S. Territories costs $4.95. International standard shipping is $9.95.
They also have rush and express shipping options both within the U.S. and internationally starting at $19.
EyeBuyDirect’s standard shipping rates start at $5.95, with international rates from $9.95-$19.
There’s also a fast 2-day delivery service on select frames if you’re in a hurry.
Warby Parker ships to the U.S., Puerto Rico, Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands, military APO/DPO/FPO addresses, and Canada only.
Standard shipping is free, including returns.
There’s an expedited shipping option available for an additional $25, which cuts down processing by a few days.
Returns
If you don’t like the glasses you bought or they don’t fit well, you can return them to all three retailers within a specific timeframe.
Zenni and Warby Parker both have 30-day return policies.
EyeBuyDirect has a 14-day return period.
Note that Zenni does not cover the cost of return shipping, and only provides a 50% refund or 100% store credit.
Return shipping is included in both Warby Parker and EyeBuyDirect’s respective return periods for a full refund.
Switch Up Your Look With Pair Eyewear’s Eyeglass Toppers
Zenni vs. EyeBuyDirect vs. Warby Parker: Prescription Eyeglasses
For our side-by-side comparisons, we chose a similar pair of eyeglasses and sunglasses from each retailer with similar lens treatments to make it as much of an apples-to-apples comparison as possible.
For prescription glasses, we picked a pair of classic round tortoise-color women’s frames made of acetate:
The lenses:
Prescription: single-vision
Lens Type: Polycarbonate (1.59 index)
Coatings: UV Protection, Anti-Reflective, Super Hydrophobic (Water Resistant), Anti-scratch
Shipping (within the U.S.):
Delivery within 7-14 business days with tracking
Extras:
Hard Case
Cleaning Cloth
Total cost (before taxes):
Zenni: $55.80
EyeBuyDirect: $64.90
Warby Parker: $95
As you can see, you can easily get a pair of prescription glasses for under $100 at all three shops. The question is, is it worth going for the cheapest option?
Let’s break down what you get from each store:
Zenni:
- Pros
- Extremely Discounted Frames
- Sells Transitions® and Trivex® Lenses
- Sells Kids Glasses
- Cons
- Paid shipping (including returns)
- Returns: 50% refund or 100% store credit only
- Does Not Accept Insurance
Tortoiseshell Round Frames $25.95, Lenses $17.95, Case $6.95, Shipping $4.95
Return Policy: 30 days for a 50% refund (excluding shipping), or 100% store credit (excluding shipping).
Warranty: 30-day replacement of broken frames
If your sole deciding factor is price, Zenni is the clear winner here.
Known for their incredibly cheap frames, they have frames as low as $6.95.
(Although I wouldn’t necessarily go for those.) Many people swear by their Zenni glasses, and it might just be the right place for you too.
Of course, you do need to be realistic about your expectations with such a cheap pair of glasses.
The quality and construction will be less sturdy, but at these prices, you could always buy another pair to replace them if they don’t last.
If you don’t like the glasses and want to return them, you’ll receive a 50% refund (or 100% store credit) and have to pay for return shipping.
EyeBuyDirect:
- Pros
- Ships Internationally
- 1-Year Frame Defect Warranty
- Sells Eyezen™ Lenses
- Offers Student Discounts
- Cons
- Short (14-day) Return Period
- UV-Protection Coating at Additional Cost
- Does Not Accept Insurance
Daybreak Frames $35, Lenses $18.95, Case (with cloth) $5, Shipping $5.95
Return Policy: 14-day return/exchange period.
Warranty: 1-year warranty on defects.
Like Zenni, EyeBuyDirect also offers some very inexpensive frames starting at $6 and a wide selection of options.
Here, the shipping made up a good portion of the overall cost because they charge $19 for shipping with tracking.
(If you don’t want to pay that much for shipping, you can go for the $5.95 option without tracking.)
Additionally, they don’t have the super hydrophobic (water-resistant) coating that both Zenni and Warby Parker offer.
If you’re unhappy with the glasses, you have up to 14 days to return them for a full refund or exchange.
On the plus side, EyeBuyDirect has a 1-year warranty against defects, so there is some piece of mind if you’re worried about the quality of the product.
However, you do need to pay for return shipping after the 14-day Fit & Style guarantee.
Warby Parker:
- Pros
- Free Shipping (including Returns)
- Free Home Try-Ons
- Retail Locations in U.S./Canada
- Eye Exams and Fittings in Select Stores
- Cons
- Less Customizable Frame Options
- Higher-Priced than Some Online Retailers
- Does not ship to all countries
Carlton $95 package price includes lenses, case, cleaning cloth, shipping
Return Policy: Full refund within 30 days, including return shipping.
Warranty: 1-year scratch-free lens warranty.
Warby Parker came in at the highest price of all three places.
Unlike Zenni and EyeBuyDirect, Warby Parker bundles all of their lens treatments and services together in a flat price that includes everything, including return shipping.
All of their glasses come with a hard case and cloth.
In addition, Warby Parker offers consumers an option that neither Zenni nor EyeBuyDirect has – the ability to try their frames on before you buy.
They have a Home Try-On Program which allows you to select up to 5 pairs of glasses that they’ll mail to you for you to try for 5 days. For free!
Learn More about Warby Parker’s Home Try-On Program
As the highest price of the three, you might be thinking “why should I pay more if I can get a cheaper pair at Zenni or EyeBuyDirect?”
For one, Warby Parker keeps up with the latest trends and is always coming out with stylish new frames and colors.
Another benefit of buying from Warby Parker is that they have several retail locations throughout the U.S. and Canada.
If your glasses don’t fit well and you are near one of their stores, you can always stop in to get your glasses adjusted.
You can even get an eye exam in some locations.
Or, if you don’t like them and prefer to return the glasses, you can ship them back within 30 days for a full refund and not be on the hook for return shipping.
Zenni vs. EyeBuyDirect vs. Warby Parker: Non-Prescription Sunglasses
For our sunglasses comparison, we chose a non-prescription silver aviator men’s frame from each company.
The lenses:
Non-prescription
Lens Type: Grey/Blue tint, CR-39/optical-quality standard lenses
Coatings: UV Protection, Anti-scratch, Anti-reflective, Polarized
Shipping (within the U.S.):
Delivery within 7-14 business days with tracking
Extras:
Hard Case
Cleaning Cloth
Total Cost (before taxes):
Zenni: $80.84
EyeBuyDirect: $90.95
Warby Parker: $145
As a general rule of thumb, sunglasses are usually more expensive than eyeglasses, particularly if they have polarized lenses. For this product comparison, Zenni again takes the cake for lowest cost, with EyeBuyDirect still under $100, and Warby Parker at the top end at $145.
Here’s the cost breakdown:
Zenni:
Premium Aviator Frames $35.95, Lenses $32.99, Case $6.95, Shipping $4.95
Return Policy: 30 days for a 50% refund (excluding shipping), or 100% store credit (excluding shipping).
Warranty: 30-day replacement of broken frames
Zenni’s silver aviator frames are made out of stainless steel and come with multiple a la carte lens options.
Aside from price, Zenni offers the most options for customizing your lenses, from multiple colors and percentage of tinting, to gradient tinting and polarization.
You can also get mirrored coatings.
The frames get high marks from reviewers and single-vision prescription lenses are even included at no additional cost.
It’s hard to beat this pair for the price and lens options.
EyeBuyDirect:
Good Vibrations Frames $45, Lenses $40, Case (with cloth) $5, Shipping $5.95
Return Policy: 14-day return/exchange period.
Warranty: 1-year warranty on defects.
EyeBuyDirect’s Good Vibrations with polarized lenses costs about the same as Zenni’s aviator.
However, the tint percentage on EyeBuyDirect’s pair is only 60% (good if you don’t want your tint too dark), compared to Zenni’s 80%.
The frame is made out of metal and has received high ratings from reviewers.
There are 3 color options for the lenses – gold, silver, and blue. Gradient tint and mirrored lenses are other options available to choose from too.
Warby Parker:
Raider $145 package price includes lenses, case, cleaning cloth, shipping
Return Policy: Full refund within 30 days, including return shipping.
Warranty: 1-year scratch-free lens warranty.
As with their eyeglasses, Warby Parker has a total package price that includes everything from lenses to shipping.
Their Raider frame in polished silver comes with a dark blue tint and polarized lenses.
At $145, they’re definitely the most expensive.
If you customize the tint with a different color or gradient, it’ll also cost you $50 extra.
Bottom Line
Getting a pair of prescription eyeglasses from any of the three companies are a great deal at under $100 a pair including shipping for a full set of prescription eyewear.
On price alone, Zenni or EyeBuyDirect will easily get you a pair for well under $100.
Though if you have an fit issues, you’re on you’re own.
Additionally, if you need to make a return, you’re responsible for the cost of return shipping (and for Zenni, you’ll get a 50% refund or 100% store credit only).
If you want to physically try a pair of frames on before you buy, either at home or in-store, Warby Parker is the way to go.
They also have the most options available after purchase if you find that you need assistance adjusting your new glasses at one of their retail locations or need to replace scratched lenses.
For sunglasses, Zenni and EyeBuyDirect both offer the most options in customizing your lenses to your liking.
They’re also the most competitive price-wise – especially Zenni, which offers single-vision prescription lenses included in the price.
Warby Parker is the simplest when it comes to the purchase process and pricing, and you can use vision benefits to pay.
Regardless of where you purchase your next pair of glasses from, keep in mind that prescription eyewear (including sunglasses) is FSA-eligible.
For even more options for buying glasses online, check out our in-depth reviews.